The Developer’s Dilemma – Part One

By Paul Dean,
Principal of Paul Dean & Associates
and Co-Founder of APOLA

Imagine that you’re a landowner whose landholdings include a pristine piece of hillside overlooking a spectacular valley through which a river winds, with unspoiled views of the surrounding countryside — an area teeming with all sorts of flora and fauna where the term “immersion in nature” does not tell the whole story, nor does it do the site justice. What is more, you have exclusive access to this land.
While this land offers amazing views, it’s unsuitable for any form of development using traditional construction methods and has historically been rented out at certain times of year for grazing. Mature deciduous and coniferous trees dot it liberally, along with plentiful shrubs, and in spring and early summer, some of the meadowland comes alive with a kaleidoscope of colourful wildflowers.
You’ve also been following tourism trends, especially those related to informed travellers who are looking for something “transformational”. You’ve read many times about the need for sustainable development, and you’ve also spotted the exponential growth of the outdoor lodging industry.
Creating something unique
Some years ago, you read The Experience Economy by Joseph Pine. And having just put down his latest work, The Transformation Economy, you dream of the possibility of creating something unique, a retreat and supporting infrastructure, where unforgettable memories might be forged for those visitors lucky enough to visit this sanctuary.
Despite the site’s location in a cooler climate, you’re buoyed by the knowledge that travellers are now researching and seeking cooler destinations in which to relax and unwind, which have made traditional destinations, especially in places like southern Europe, less attractive, as a consequence of a warming climate.
You decide to explore this idea further and get to work on the internet to see what you can learn. Your business background and commercial acumen give you the confidence to ask the right questions and to persevere, to get the best possible answers.
Examples in different parts of the world
You scrutinise what other successful pioneers and developers have done in different parts of the world, especially in the USA, Africa, Europe, Australia and those parts of Asia where glamping is now well established. You have identified numerous different types of glamping accommodations, the use of new materials, the application of new technologies to help develop off-grid sites and spoken to some of your chums in the hospitality industry to get their valuable feedback.
You’ve found the APOLA website which turns out to be a goldmine in terms of industry knowledge, insights and know-how.
You’re now wondering where to start, to turn your ideas into a viable concept. You want to create something defined by your environmental and sustainability ambitions. You envision an eco-conscious luxury retreat that embodies cutting-edge sustainability and delivers profound guest experiences within the 45 acres (18ha) that you have earmarked for your project.
But where do you start?
You are also cognisant of the needs of your local village and your farming community. You want to examine how this local community might benefit from your development in terms of job creation, provision of services by local suppliers and especially, the “farm to table” dining opportunities which might be captured, which could benefit all your local producers.
Let’s assume that you [or your appointed planning advisors] have already engaged with your local planning authority. As a result, you have been assured that a development of the type proposed will receive planning approval, subject to a reasonable set of conditions.
Begin with your site analysis, to identify key elements of the land. Consider a topographical analysis, along with an underlying soil and strata analysis that evaluates the physical, chemical, and mechanical layers of the earth beneath your development site to determine load-bearing capacity, settlement risks, and foundation requirements.
Be sure to identify all the natural features of the site and consider how they might be leveraged for the benefit of the project. You already control the exclusive access to the site, so there shouldn’t be any logistical issues. Then on to the area programming.
Low density – your greatest asset
Developing a 30- to 40-unit luxury tented retreat on a 45 or so acre site gives you an incredibly generous land-to-key ratio of around 1.25 acres (0.5ha) per tent. On a 45-acre luxury site, your built structures should occupy only a small fraction of the land, leaving the rest for buffer zones, trails, and scenery. For high-end or luxury glamping projects, this low density is arguably your greatest asset. You are selling seclusion, acoustic privacy, and untouched nature, rather than just an upscale tent in a field.
If proof were needed, refer to the Shinta Mani Wild project in Cambodia. This Bill Bensley-designed project comprises 15 individually themed luxury stilted canvas tents, many overlooking waterfalls, set within indigenous Cambodian forest. Due to low density design, seasonal rates range from US$2,000 per night during rainy months to around US$4,000 in peak (dry) season.
The low density “immersion in nature” factor is a critical element. Density can materially compromise the core value proposition of a pristine-location glamping retreat. It is one of the most important design issues to get right before fixing the number of accommodation units. As noted above, your guests are not simply renting a tent or cabin. They are buying the feeling of having temporarily escaped into nature. If they can see, hear, or constantly encounter other guests, that psychological proposition, and any sense of exclusivity, starts to break down.
Law of diminishing returns
There is an important asymmetry to consider on this density question. Increasing density may increase the revenue per acre much faster than it increases guest value. But at some point, each additional tent or cabin produces relatively little incremental revenue while disproportionately damaging the guest experience of the occupants of the existing cabins.
You must avoid thinking about “how many units per acre” in isolation. For a nature-based, luxury glamping retreat, the more useful question is: “Can my guests sit outside their tents or cabins and genuinely believe that they are alone in nature? Ideally, the answer should be yes. That doesn’t necessarily mean the cabins have to be hundreds of metres apart. Clever use of topography, vegetation and orientation can create considerable psychological separation and a perception of private immersion in nature.
The business dream is starting to take shape.
—
In Part Two, we will consider likely or preferred target markets and how to reach them.
In Part Three, we will identify the likely soft costs, space or area programming for the site, including engineering work, platforms, decks and means of access; also front and back-of-house requirements, the preferred accommodation types, utility needs and the amenity strategy.
In Part Four, we will identify key contractors and suppliers, consider the estimated useful life and ongoing maintenance costs for the chosen accommodation types. We will address the interior design brief, development budget and financial feasibility analysis.





